./Ultimate.py --spec ../../sv-benchmarks/c/properties/no-data-race.prp --file ../../sv-benchmarks/c/pthread-deagle/airline-25.i --full-output --architecture 32bit -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Checking for data races Using default analysis Version 9bd2c7ff Calling Ultimate with: /usr/lib/jvm/java-11-openjdk-amd64/bin/java -Dosgi.configuration.area=/tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/data/config -Xmx15G -Xms4m -jar /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/plugins/org.eclipse.equinox.launcher_1.5.800.v20200727-1323.jar -data @noDefault -ultimatedata /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/data -tc /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/config/GemCutterReach.xml -i ../../sv-benchmarks/c/pthread-deagle/airline-25.i -s /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/config/svcomp-DataRace-32bit-GemCutter_Default.epf --cacsl2boogietranslator.entry.function main --witnessprinter.witness.directory /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW --witnessprinter.witness.filename witness --witnessprinter.write.witness.besides.input.file false --witnessprinter.graph.data.specification CHECK( init(main()), LTL(G ! data-race) ) --witnessprinter.graph.data.producer GemCutter --witnessprinter.graph.data.architecture 32bit --witnessprinter.graph.data.programhash a0d81069750f24e52e04bdb7efecd6d77b64aec41e058c154f75fbba11e6c11d --- Real Ultimate output --- This is Ultimate 0.2.3-dev-9bd2c7f [2023-11-17 22:44:38,811 INFO L188 SettingsManager]: Resetting all preferences to default values... [2023-11-17 22:44:38,882 INFO L114 SettingsManager]: Loading settings from /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/config/svcomp-DataRace-32bit-GemCutter_Default.epf [2023-11-17 22:44:38,889 WARN L101 SettingsManager]: Preference file contains the following unknown settings: [2023-11-17 22:44:38,889 WARN L103 SettingsManager]: * de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.core.Log level for class [2023-11-17 22:44:38,916 INFO L130 SettingsManager]: Preferences different from defaults after loading the file: [2023-11-17 22:44:38,916 INFO L151 SettingsManager]: Preferences of UltimateCore differ from their defaults: [2023-11-17 22:44:38,917 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Log level for class=de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.lib.smtlibutils.quantifier.QuantifierPusher=ERROR; [2023-11-17 22:44:38,918 INFO L151 SettingsManager]: Preferences of Boogie Procedure Inliner differ from their defaults: [2023-11-17 22:44:38,919 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Ignore calls to procedures called more than once=ONLY_FOR_SEQUENTIAL_PROGRAMS [2023-11-17 22:44:38,919 INFO L151 SettingsManager]: Preferences of BlockEncodingV2 differ from their defaults: [2023-11-17 22:44:38,920 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Create parallel compositions if possible=false [2023-11-17 22:44:38,921 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Use SBE=true [2023-11-17 22:44:38,921 INFO L151 SettingsManager]: Preferences of CACSL2BoogieTranslator differ from their defaults: [2023-11-17 22:44:38,922 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Pointer base address is valid at dereference=IGNORE [2023-11-17 22:44:38,923 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * sizeof long=4 [2023-11-17 22:44:38,923 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Overapproximate operations on floating types=true [2023-11-17 22:44:38,924 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * sizeof POINTER=4 [2023-11-17 22:44:38,924 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Check division by zero=IGNORE [2023-11-17 22:44:38,925 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Pointer to allocated memory at dereference=IGNORE [2023-11-17 22:44:38,925 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * If two pointers are subtracted or compared they have the same base address=IGNORE [2023-11-17 22:44:38,926 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Check array bounds for arrays that are off heap=IGNORE [2023-11-17 22:44:38,927 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Check absence of data races in concurrent programs=true [2023-11-17 22:44:38,927 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Check unreachability of reach_error function=false [2023-11-17 22:44:38,928 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * sizeof long double=12 [2023-11-17 22:44:38,928 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Check if freed pointer was valid=false [2023-11-17 22:44:38,929 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Use constant arrays=true [2023-11-17 22:44:38,929 INFO L151 SettingsManager]: Preferences of RCFGBuilder differ from their defaults: [2023-11-17 22:44:38,930 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Size of a code block=SequenceOfStatements [2023-11-17 22:44:38,930 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * To the following directory=./dump/ [2023-11-17 22:44:38,931 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * SMT solver=External_DefaultMode [2023-11-17 22:44:38,931 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Command for external solver=z3 SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -memory:2024 -smt2 -in -t:2000 [2023-11-17 22:44:38,932 INFO L151 SettingsManager]: Preferences of TraceAbstraction differ from their defaults: [2023-11-17 22:44:38,932 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Compute Interpolants along a Counterexample=FPandBP [2023-11-17 22:44:38,932 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Positions where we compute the Hoare Annotation=LoopHeads [2023-11-17 22:44:38,933 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Trace refinement strategy=CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:38,933 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Command for external solver=z3 SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -memory:2024 -smt2 -in [2023-11-17 22:44:38,934 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Apply one-shot large block encoding in concurrent analysis=false [2023-11-17 22:44:38,934 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Abstraction used for commutativity in POR=VARIABLES_GLOBAL [2023-11-17 22:44:38,935 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Automaton type used in concurrency analysis=PARTIAL_ORDER_FA [2023-11-17 22:44:38,935 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Compute Hoare Annotation of negated interpolant automaton, abstraction and CFG=true [2023-11-17 22:44:38,936 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * CEGAR restart behaviour=ONE_CEGAR_PER_THREAD_INSTANCE [2023-11-17 22:44:38,936 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * Partial Order Reduction in concurrent analysis=PERSISTENT_SLEEP_NEW_STATES_FIXEDORDER [2023-11-17 22:44:38,936 INFO L153 SettingsManager]: * SMT solver=External_ModelsAndUnsatCoreMode WARNING: An illegal reflective access operation has occurred WARNING: Illegal reflective access by com.sun.xml.bind.v2.runtime.reflect.opt.Injector$1 (file:/tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/plugins/com.sun.xml.bind_2.2.0.v201505121915.jar) to method java.lang.ClassLoader.defineClass(java.lang.String,byte[],int,int) WARNING: Please consider reporting this to the maintainers of com.sun.xml.bind.v2.runtime.reflect.opt.Injector$1 WARNING: Use --illegal-access=warn to enable warnings of further illegal reflective access operations WARNING: All illegal access operations will be denied in a future release Applying setting for plugin de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator: Entry function -> main Applying setting for plugin de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.witnessprinter: Witness directory -> /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW Applying setting for plugin de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.witnessprinter: Witness filename -> witness Applying setting for plugin de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.witnessprinter: Write witness besides input file -> false Applying setting for plugin de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.witnessprinter: Graph data specification -> CHECK( init(main()), LTL(G ! data-race) ) Applying setting for plugin de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.witnessprinter: Graph data producer -> GemCutter Applying setting for plugin de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.witnessprinter: Graph data architecture -> 32bit Applying setting for plugin de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.witnessprinter: Graph data programhash -> a0d81069750f24e52e04bdb7efecd6d77b64aec41e058c154f75fbba11e6c11d [2023-11-17 22:44:39,186 INFO L75 nceAwareModelManager]: Repository-Root is: /tmp [2023-11-17 22:44:39,226 INFO L261 ainManager$Toolchain]: [Toolchain 1]: Applicable parser(s) successfully (re)initialized [2023-11-17 22:44:39,228 INFO L217 ainManager$Toolchain]: [Toolchain 1]: Toolchain selected. [2023-11-17 22:44:39,229 INFO L270 PluginConnector]: Initializing CDTParser... [2023-11-17 22:44:39,230 INFO L274 PluginConnector]: CDTParser initialized [2023-11-17 22:44:39,231 INFO L431 ainManager$Toolchain]: [Toolchain 1]: Parsing single file: /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/../../sv-benchmarks/c/pthread-deagle/airline-25.i [2023-11-17 22:44:42,407 INFO L533 CDTParser]: Created temporary CDT project at NULL [2023-11-17 22:44:42,695 INFO L384 CDTParser]: Found 1 translation units. [2023-11-17 22:44:42,696 INFO L180 CDTParser]: Scanning /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/sv-benchmarks/c/pthread-deagle/airline-25.i [2023-11-17 22:44:42,716 INFO L427 CDTParser]: About to delete temporary CDT project at /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/data/c27026d78/d9f06ad8262e4c2d99e449b84cf523c2/FLAG42e521487 [2023-11-17 22:44:42,731 INFO L435 CDTParser]: Successfully deleted /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/data/c27026d78/d9f06ad8262e4c2d99e449b84cf523c2 [2023-11-17 22:44:42,739 INFO L299 ainManager$Toolchain]: ####################### [Toolchain 1] ####################### [2023-11-17 22:44:42,741 INFO L133 ToolchainWalker]: Walking toolchain with 6 elements. [2023-11-17 22:44:42,742 INFO L112 PluginConnector]: ------------------------CACSL2BoogieTranslator---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:42,743 INFO L270 PluginConnector]: Initializing CACSL2BoogieTranslator... [2023-11-17 22:44:42,752 INFO L274 PluginConnector]: CACSL2BoogieTranslator initialized [2023-11-17 22:44:42,753 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer ACSLObjectContainerObserver from plugin CACSL2BoogieTranslator for "CDTParser AST 17.11 10:44:42" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:42,754 INFO L204 PluginConnector]: Invalid model from CACSL2BoogieTranslator for observer de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator.ACSLObjectContainerObserver@70f23da5 and model type de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:42, skipping insertion in model container [2023-11-17 22:44:42,754 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer CACSL2BoogieTranslatorObserver from plugin CACSL2BoogieTranslator for "CDTParser AST 17.11 10:44:42" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:42,819 INFO L177 MainTranslator]: Built tables and reachable declarations [2023-11-17 22:44:43,313 INFO L209 PostProcessor]: Analyzing one entry point: main [2023-11-17 22:44:43,324 INFO L202 MainTranslator]: Completed pre-run [2023-11-17 22:44:43,380 INFO L209 PostProcessor]: Analyzing one entry point: main [2023-11-17 22:44:43,416 WARN L675 CHandler]: The function __VERIFIER_atomic_begin is called, but not defined or handled by StandardFunctionHandler. [2023-11-17 22:44:43,416 WARN L675 CHandler]: The function __VERIFIER_atomic_end is called, but not defined or handled by StandardFunctionHandler. [2023-11-17 22:44:43,424 INFO L206 MainTranslator]: Completed translation [2023-11-17 22:44:43,425 INFO L201 PluginConnector]: Adding new model de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43 WrapperNode [2023-11-17 22:44:43,425 INFO L131 PluginConnector]: ------------------------ END CACSL2BoogieTranslator---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:43,426 INFO L112 PluginConnector]: ------------------------Boogie Procedure Inliner---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:43,427 INFO L270 PluginConnector]: Initializing Boogie Procedure Inliner... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,427 INFO L274 PluginConnector]: Boogie Procedure Inliner initialized [2023-11-17 22:44:43,434 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer TypeChecker from plugin Boogie Procedure Inliner for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,456 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer Inliner from plugin Boogie Procedure Inliner for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,480 INFO L138 Inliner]: procedures = 162, calls = 24, calls flagged for inlining = 3, calls inlined = 3, statements flattened = 84 [2023-11-17 22:44:43,481 INFO L131 PluginConnector]: ------------------------ END Boogie Procedure Inliner---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:43,482 INFO L112 PluginConnector]: ------------------------Boogie Preprocessor---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:43,482 INFO L270 PluginConnector]: Initializing Boogie Preprocessor... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,482 INFO L274 PluginConnector]: Boogie Preprocessor initialized [2023-11-17 22:44:43,491 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer EnsureBoogieModelObserver from plugin Boogie Preprocessor for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,492 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer TypeChecker from plugin Boogie Preprocessor for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,496 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer ConstExpander from plugin Boogie Preprocessor for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,496 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer StructExpander from plugin Boogie Preprocessor for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,510 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer UnstructureCode from plugin Boogie Preprocessor for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,513 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer FunctionInliner from plugin Boogie Preprocessor for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,516 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer LTLStepAnnotator from plugin Boogie Preprocessor for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,517 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer BoogieSymbolTableConstructor from plugin Boogie Preprocessor for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,521 INFO L131 PluginConnector]: ------------------------ END Boogie Preprocessor---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:43,522 INFO L112 PluginConnector]: ------------------------RCFGBuilder---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:43,522 INFO L270 PluginConnector]: Initializing RCFGBuilder... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,522 INFO L274 PluginConnector]: RCFGBuilder initialized [2023-11-17 22:44:43,523 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer RCFGBuilderObserver from plugin RCFGBuilder for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (1/1) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:43,543 INFO L173 SolverBuilder]: Constructing external solver with command: z3 SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -memory:2024 -smt2 -in -t:2000 [2023-11-17 22:44:43,560 INFO L189 MonitoredProcess]: No working directory specified, using /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 [2023-11-17 22:44:43,572 INFO L229 MonitoredProcess]: Starting monitored process 1 with /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -memory:2024 -smt2 -in -t:2000 (exit command is (exit), workingDir is null) [2023-11-17 22:44:43,604 INFO L327 MonitoredProcess]: [MP /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -memory:2024 -smt2 -in -t:2000 (1)] Waiting until timeout for monitored process [2023-11-17 22:44:43,615 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure read~int [2023-11-17 22:44:43,616 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure write~int [2023-11-17 22:44:43,616 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure __VERIFIER_atomic_begin [2023-11-17 22:44:43,616 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure #Ultimate.allocInit [2023-11-17 22:44:43,616 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure #Ultimate.allocOnStack [2023-11-17 22:44:43,617 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure salethread [2023-11-17 22:44:43,617 INFO L138 BoogieDeclarations]: Found implementation of procedure salethread [2023-11-17 22:44:43,617 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure ULTIMATE.dealloc [2023-11-17 22:44:43,618 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure write~init~int [2023-11-17 22:44:43,620 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure __VERIFIER_atomic_end [2023-11-17 22:44:43,620 INFO L130 BoogieDeclarations]: Found specification of procedure ULTIMATE.start [2023-11-17 22:44:43,621 INFO L138 BoogieDeclarations]: Found implementation of procedure ULTIMATE.start [2023-11-17 22:44:43,622 WARN L210 CfgBuilder]: User set CodeBlockSize to SequenceOfStatements but program contains fork statements. Overwriting the user preferences and setting CodeBlockSize to OneNontrivialStatement [2023-11-17 22:44:43,814 INFO L236 CfgBuilder]: Building ICFG [2023-11-17 22:44:43,817 INFO L262 CfgBuilder]: Building CFG for each procedure with an implementation [2023-11-17 22:44:44,124 INFO L277 CfgBuilder]: Performing block encoding [2023-11-17 22:44:44,179 INFO L297 CfgBuilder]: Using the 1 location(s) as analysis (start of procedure ULTIMATE.start) [2023-11-17 22:44:44,180 INFO L302 CfgBuilder]: Removed 2 assume(true) statements. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,184 INFO L201 PluginConnector]: Adding new model de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.rcfgbuilder CFG 17.11 10:44:44 BoogieIcfgContainer [2023-11-17 22:44:44,185 INFO L131 PluginConnector]: ------------------------ END RCFGBuilder---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:44,189 INFO L112 PluginConnector]: ------------------------TraceAbstraction---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:44,191 INFO L270 PluginConnector]: Initializing TraceAbstraction... [2023-11-17 22:44:44,200 INFO L274 PluginConnector]: TraceAbstraction initialized [2023-11-17 22:44:44,200 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer TraceAbstractionObserver from plugin TraceAbstraction for "CDTParser AST 17.11 10:44:42" (1/3) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:44,201 INFO L204 PluginConnector]: Invalid model from TraceAbstraction for observer de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.traceabstraction.TraceAbstractionObserver@4f8fe0a0 and model type de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.traceabstraction AST 17.11 10:44:44, skipping insertion in model container [2023-11-17 22:44:44,201 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer TraceAbstractionObserver from plugin TraceAbstraction for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator AST 17.11 10:44:43" (2/3) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:44,203 INFO L204 PluginConnector]: Invalid model from TraceAbstraction for observer de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.traceabstraction.TraceAbstractionObserver@4f8fe0a0 and model type de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.traceabstraction AST 17.11 10:44:44, skipping insertion in model container [2023-11-17 22:44:44,205 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer TraceAbstractionObserver from plugin TraceAbstraction for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.rcfgbuilder CFG 17.11 10:44:44" (3/3) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:44,206 INFO L112 eAbstractionObserver]: Analyzing ICFG airline-25.i [2023-11-17 22:44:44,216 WARN L145 ceAbstractionStarter]: Switching off computation of Hoare annotation because input is a concurrent program [2023-11-17 22:44:44,229 INFO L203 ceAbstractionStarter]: Automizer settings: Hoare:false NWA Interpolation:FPandBP Determinization: PREDICATE_ABSTRACTION [2023-11-17 22:44:44,229 INFO L162 ceAbstractionStarter]: Applying trace abstraction to program that has 9 error locations. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,229 INFO L514 ceAbstractionStarter]: Constructing petrified ICFG for 1 thread instances. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,289 INFO L144 ThreadInstanceAdder]: Constructed 1 joinOtherThreadTransitions. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,336 INFO L100 denceProviderFactory]: Independence Relation #1: [IndependenceType=SEMANTIC, AbstractionType=VARIABLES_GLOBAL, UseConditional=true, UseSemiCommutativity=true, Solver=Z3, SolverTimeout=1000ms] [2023-11-17 22:44:44,336 INFO L173 SolverBuilder]: Constructing external solver with command: z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 [2023-11-17 22:44:44,336 INFO L189 MonitoredProcess]: No working directory specified, using /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 [2023-11-17 22:44:44,338 INFO L229 MonitoredProcess]: Starting monitored process 2 with /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 (exit command is (exit), workingDir is null) [2023-11-17 22:44:44,356 INFO L327 MonitoredProcess]: [MP /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 (2)] Waiting until timeout for monitored process [2023-11-17 22:44:44,388 INFO L159 artialOrderCegarLoop]: Running PartialOrderCegarLoop with 1 independence relations. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,400 INFO L356 AbstractCegarLoop]: ======== Iteration 0 == of CEGAR loop == salethreadThread1of1ForFork0 ======== [2023-11-17 22:44:44,407 INFO L357 AbstractCegarLoop]: Settings: SEPARATE_VIOLATION_CHECK=true, mInterprocedural=true, mMaxIterations=1000000, mWatchIteration=1000000, mArtifact=RCFG, mInterpolation=FPandBP, mInterpolantAutomaton=STRAIGHT_LINE, mDumpAutomata=false, mAutomataFormat=ATS_NUMERATE, mDumpPath=., mDeterminiation=PREDICATE_ABSTRACTION, mMinimize=MINIMIZE_SEVPA, mHoare=true, mAutomataTypeConcurrency=PARTIAL_ORDER_FA, mHoareTripleChecks=INCREMENTAL, mHoareAnnotationPositions=LoopHeads, mDumpOnlyReuseAutomata=false, mLimitTraceHistogram=0, mErrorLocTimeLimit=0, mLimitPathProgramCount=0, mCollectInterpolantStatistics=true, mHeuristicEmptinessCheck=false, mHeuristicEmptinessCheckAStarHeuristic=ZERO, mHeuristicEmptinessCheckAStarHeuristicRandomSeed=1337, mHeuristicEmptinessCheckSmtFeatureScoringMethod=DAGSIZE, mSMTFeatureExtraction=false, mSMTFeatureExtractionDumpPath=., mOverrideInterpolantAutomaton=false, mMcrInterpolantMethod=WP, mPorIndependenceSettings=[Lde.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.lib.tracecheckerutils.partialorder.independence.IndependenceSettings;@637b9ebc, mLbeIndependenceSettings=[IndependenceType=SEMANTIC, AbstractionType=NONE, UseConditional=false, UseSemiCommutativity=true, Solver=Z3, SolverTimeout=1000ms] [2023-11-17 22:44:44,407 INFO L358 AbstractCegarLoop]: Starting to check reachability of 4 error locations. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,637 INFO L420 AbstractCegarLoop]: === Iteration 1 === Targeting salethreadErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE === [salethreadErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (and 1 more)] === [2023-11-17 22:44:44,641 INFO L160 PredicateUnifier]: Initialized classic predicate unifier [2023-11-17 22:44:44,642 INFO L85 PathProgramCache]: Analyzing trace with hash 782400796, now seen corresponding path program 1 times [2023-11-17 22:44:44,652 INFO L118 FreeRefinementEngine]: Executing refinement strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:44,652 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using trace check IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [778867628] [2023-11-17 22:44:44,653 INFO L95 rtionOrderModulation]: Keeping assertion order NOT_INCREMENTALLY [2023-11-17 22:44:44,653 INFO L127 SolverBuilder]: Constructing new instance of SMTInterpol with explicit timeout -1 ms and remaining time -1 ms [2023-11-17 22:44:44,817 INFO L136 AnnotateAndAsserter]: Conjunction of SSA is unsat [2023-11-17 22:44:44,919 INFO L134 CoverageAnalysis]: Checked inductivity of 0 backedges. 0 proven. 0 refuted. 0 times theorem prover too weak. 0 trivial. 0 not checked. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,919 INFO L136 FreeRefinementEngine]: Strategy CAMEL found an infeasible trace [2023-11-17 22:44:44,919 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant generator IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [778867628] [2023-11-17 22:44:44,920 INFO L158 FreeRefinementEngine]: IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [778867628] provided 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences [2023-11-17 22:44:44,920 INFO L185 FreeRefinementEngine]: Found 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,921 INFO L198 FreeRefinementEngine]: Number of different interpolants: perfect sequences [2] imperfect sequences [] total 2 [2023-11-17 22:44:44,922 INFO L121 tionRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant automaton builder IpAbStrategyModuleStraightlineAll [224269470] [2023-11-17 22:44:44,923 INFO L85 oduleStraightlineAll]: Using 1 perfect interpolants to construct interpolant automaton [2023-11-17 22:44:44,927 INFO L571 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has 3 states [2023-11-17 22:44:44,927 INFO L100 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using predicate unifier PredicateUnifier provided by strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:44,952 INFO L143 InterpolantAutomaton]: Constructing interpolant automaton starting with 3 interpolants. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,956 INFO L145 InterpolantAutomaton]: CoverageRelationStatistics Valid=3, Invalid=3, Unknown=0, NotChecked=0, Total=6 [2023-11-17 22:44:44,958 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:44,962 INFO L495 AbstractCegarLoop]: Abstraction has currently 0 states, but on-demand construction may add more states [2023-11-17 22:44:44,963 INFO L496 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has has 3 states, 2 states have (on average 14.0) internal successors, (28), 3 states have internal predecessors, (28), 0 states have call successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have return successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have call successors, (0) [2023-11-17 22:44:44,963 INFO L154 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to On-DemandConstruction mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,015 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 3 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,015 WARN L477 AbstractCegarLoop]: Destroyed unattended storables created during the last iteration: SelfDestructingSolverStorable0 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,016 INFO L420 AbstractCegarLoop]: === Iteration 2 === Targeting salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE === [salethreadErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (and 1 more)] === [2023-11-17 22:44:45,016 INFO L160 PredicateUnifier]: Initialized classic predicate unifier [2023-11-17 22:44:45,017 INFO L85 PathProgramCache]: Analyzing trace with hash -285103789, now seen corresponding path program 1 times [2023-11-17 22:44:45,017 INFO L118 FreeRefinementEngine]: Executing refinement strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:45,017 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using trace check IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [1271890876] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,017 INFO L95 rtionOrderModulation]: Keeping assertion order NOT_INCREMENTALLY [2023-11-17 22:44:45,018 INFO L127 SolverBuilder]: Constructing new instance of SMTInterpol with explicit timeout -1 ms and remaining time -1 ms [2023-11-17 22:44:45,050 INFO L136 AnnotateAndAsserter]: Conjunction of SSA is unsat [2023-11-17 22:44:45,107 INFO L134 CoverageAnalysis]: Checked inductivity of 0 backedges. 0 proven. 0 refuted. 0 times theorem prover too weak. 0 trivial. 0 not checked. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,108 INFO L136 FreeRefinementEngine]: Strategy CAMEL found an infeasible trace [2023-11-17 22:44:45,108 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant generator IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [1271890876] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,108 INFO L158 FreeRefinementEngine]: IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [1271890876] provided 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences [2023-11-17 22:44:45,108 INFO L185 FreeRefinementEngine]: Found 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,109 INFO L198 FreeRefinementEngine]: Number of different interpolants: perfect sequences [2] imperfect sequences [] total 2 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,109 INFO L121 tionRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant automaton builder IpAbStrategyModuleStraightlineAll [306392619] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,109 INFO L85 oduleStraightlineAll]: Using 1 perfect interpolants to construct interpolant automaton [2023-11-17 22:44:45,110 INFO L571 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has 3 states [2023-11-17 22:44:45,111 INFO L100 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using predicate unifier PredicateUnifier provided by strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:45,112 INFO L143 InterpolantAutomaton]: Constructing interpolant automaton starting with 3 interpolants. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,112 INFO L145 InterpolantAutomaton]: CoverageRelationStatistics Valid=3, Invalid=3, Unknown=0, NotChecked=0, Total=6 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,112 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,113 INFO L495 AbstractCegarLoop]: Abstraction has currently 0 states, but on-demand construction may add more states [2023-11-17 22:44:45,114 INFO L496 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has has 3 states, 2 states have (on average 15.5) internal successors, (31), 3 states have internal predecessors, (31), 0 states have call successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have return successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have call successors, (0) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,114 INFO L154 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to On-DemandConstruction mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 3 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,114 INFO L154 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to On-DemandConstruction mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,294 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 3 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,294 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 3 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,297 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result SAFE for location salethreadErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (3 of 4 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,298 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result SAFE for location salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (2 of 4 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,298 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result SAFE for location salethreadErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (1 of 4 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,298 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result SAFE for location salethreadErr3ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (0 of 4 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,299 WARN L477 AbstractCegarLoop]: Destroyed unattended storables created during the last iteration: SelfDestructingSolverStorable1 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,318 INFO L445 BasicCegarLoop]: Path program histogram: [1, 1] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,319 INFO L307 ceAbstractionStarter]: Result for error location salethreadThread1of1ForFork0 was SAFE,SAFE,SAFE,SAFE (1/2) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,328 INFO L100 denceProviderFactory]: Independence Relation #1: [IndependenceType=SEMANTIC, AbstractionType=VARIABLES_GLOBAL, UseConditional=true, UseSemiCommutativity=true, Solver=Z3, SolverTimeout=1000ms] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,328 INFO L173 SolverBuilder]: Constructing external solver with command: z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,329 INFO L189 MonitoredProcess]: No working directory specified, using /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,369 INFO L229 MonitoredProcess]: Starting monitored process 3 with /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 (exit command is (exit), workingDir is null) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,378 INFO L159 artialOrderCegarLoop]: Running PartialOrderCegarLoop with 1 independence relations. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,379 INFO L356 AbstractCegarLoop]: ======== Iteration 0 == of CEGAR loop == ULTIMATE.start ======== [2023-11-17 22:44:45,380 INFO L357 AbstractCegarLoop]: Settings: SEPARATE_VIOLATION_CHECK=true, mInterprocedural=true, mMaxIterations=1000000, mWatchIteration=1000000, mArtifact=RCFG, mInterpolation=FPandBP, mInterpolantAutomaton=STRAIGHT_LINE, mDumpAutomata=false, mAutomataFormat=ATS_NUMERATE, mDumpPath=., mDeterminiation=PREDICATE_ABSTRACTION, mMinimize=MINIMIZE_SEVPA, mHoare=true, mAutomataTypeConcurrency=PARTIAL_ORDER_FA, mHoareTripleChecks=INCREMENTAL, mHoareAnnotationPositions=LoopHeads, mDumpOnlyReuseAutomata=false, mLimitTraceHistogram=0, mErrorLocTimeLimit=0, mLimitPathProgramCount=0, mCollectInterpolantStatistics=true, mHeuristicEmptinessCheck=false, mHeuristicEmptinessCheckAStarHeuristic=ZERO, mHeuristicEmptinessCheckAStarHeuristicRandomSeed=1337, mHeuristicEmptinessCheckSmtFeatureScoringMethod=DAGSIZE, mSMTFeatureExtraction=false, mSMTFeatureExtractionDumpPath=., mOverrideInterpolantAutomaton=false, mMcrInterpolantMethod=WP, mPorIndependenceSettings=[Lde.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.lib.tracecheckerutils.partialorder.independence.IndependenceSettings;@637b9ebc, mLbeIndependenceSettings=[IndependenceType=SEMANTIC, AbstractionType=NONE, UseConditional=false, UseSemiCommutativity=true, Solver=Z3, SolverTimeout=1000ms] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,380 INFO L358 AbstractCegarLoop]: Starting to check reachability of 6 error locations. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,391 INFO L327 MonitoredProcess]: [MP /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 (3)] Waiting until timeout for monitored process [2023-11-17 22:44:45,405 INFO L420 AbstractCegarLoop]: === Iteration 1 === Targeting ULTIMATE.startErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE === [ULTIMATE.startErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, ULTIMATE.startErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, ULTIMATE.startErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (and 3 more)] === [2023-11-17 22:44:45,405 INFO L160 PredicateUnifier]: Initialized classic predicate unifier [2023-11-17 22:44:45,405 INFO L85 PathProgramCache]: Analyzing trace with hash 1588346089, now seen corresponding path program 1 times [2023-11-17 22:44:45,406 INFO L118 FreeRefinementEngine]: Executing refinement strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:45,406 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using trace check IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [1187659828] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,406 INFO L95 rtionOrderModulation]: Keeping assertion order NOT_INCREMENTALLY [2023-11-17 22:44:45,406 INFO L127 SolverBuilder]: Constructing new instance of SMTInterpol with explicit timeout -1 ms and remaining time -1 ms [2023-11-17 22:44:45,428 INFO L136 AnnotateAndAsserter]: Conjunction of SSA is unsat [2023-11-17 22:44:45,472 INFO L134 CoverageAnalysis]: Checked inductivity of 0 backedges. 0 proven. 0 refuted. 0 times theorem prover too weak. 0 trivial. 0 not checked. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,483 INFO L136 FreeRefinementEngine]: Strategy CAMEL found an infeasible trace [2023-11-17 22:44:45,483 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant generator IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [1187659828] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,483 INFO L158 FreeRefinementEngine]: IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [1187659828] provided 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences [2023-11-17 22:44:45,483 INFO L185 FreeRefinementEngine]: Found 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,484 INFO L198 FreeRefinementEngine]: Number of different interpolants: perfect sequences [1] imperfect sequences [] total 1 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,484 INFO L121 tionRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant automaton builder IpAbStrategyModuleStraightlineAll [254125856] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,484 INFO L85 oduleStraightlineAll]: Using 1 perfect interpolants to construct interpolant automaton [2023-11-17 22:44:45,484 INFO L571 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has 2 states [2023-11-17 22:44:45,485 INFO L100 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using predicate unifier PredicateUnifier provided by strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:45,485 INFO L143 InterpolantAutomaton]: Constructing interpolant automaton starting with 2 interpolants. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,486 INFO L145 InterpolantAutomaton]: CoverageRelationStatistics Valid=1, Invalid=1, Unknown=0, NotChecked=0, Total=2 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,486 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,486 INFO L495 AbstractCegarLoop]: Abstraction has currently 0 states, but on-demand construction may add more states [2023-11-17 22:44:45,487 INFO L496 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has has 2 states, 1 states have (on average 17.0) internal successors, (17), 2 states have internal predecessors, (17), 0 states have call successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have return successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have call successors, (0) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,487 INFO L154 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to On-DemandConstruction mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,600 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,602 WARN L477 AbstractCegarLoop]: Destroyed unattended storables created during the last iteration: SelfDestructingSolverStorable2 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,602 INFO L420 AbstractCegarLoop]: === Iteration 2 === Targeting ULTIMATE.startErr0INUSE_VIOLATIONSUFFICIENT_THREAD_INSTANCES === [ULTIMATE.startErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, ULTIMATE.startErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, ULTIMATE.startErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (and 3 more)] === [2023-11-17 22:44:45,607 INFO L160 PredicateUnifier]: Initialized classic predicate unifier [2023-11-17 22:44:45,607 INFO L85 PathProgramCache]: Analyzing trace with hash -735380927, now seen corresponding path program 1 times [2023-11-17 22:44:45,607 INFO L118 FreeRefinementEngine]: Executing refinement strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:45,607 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using trace check IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [997021665] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,608 INFO L95 rtionOrderModulation]: Keeping assertion order NOT_INCREMENTALLY [2023-11-17 22:44:45,608 INFO L127 SolverBuilder]: Constructing new instance of SMTInterpol with explicit timeout -1 ms and remaining time -1 ms [2023-11-17 22:44:45,662 INFO L136 AnnotateAndAsserter]: Conjunction of SSA is sat [2023-11-17 22:44:45,663 INFO L356 TraceCheck]: Trace is feasible, we will do another trace check, this time with branch encoders. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,696 INFO L136 AnnotateAndAsserter]: Conjunction of SSA is sat [2023-11-17 22:44:45,737 INFO L130 FreeRefinementEngine]: Strategy CAMEL found a feasible trace [2023-11-17 22:44:45,738 INFO L360 BasicCegarLoop]: Counterexample is feasible [2023-11-17 22:44:45,738 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNSAFE for location ULTIMATE.startErr0INUSE_VIOLATIONSUFFICIENT_THREAD_INSTANCES (5 of 6 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,738 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNKNOWN for location ULTIMATE.startErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (4 of 6 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,739 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNKNOWN for location ULTIMATE.startErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (3 of 6 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,739 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNKNOWN for location ULTIMATE.startErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (2 of 6 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,739 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNKNOWN for location ULTIMATE.startErr4ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (1 of 6 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,739 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNKNOWN for location ULTIMATE.startErr3ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (0 of 6 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,740 WARN L477 AbstractCegarLoop]: Destroyed unattended storables created during the last iteration: SelfDestructingSolverStorable3 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,749 INFO L445 BasicCegarLoop]: Path program histogram: [1, 1] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,750 INFO L307 ceAbstractionStarter]: Result for error location ULTIMATE.start was UNSAFE,UNKNOWN,UNKNOWN,UNKNOWN,UNKNOWN,UNKNOWN (2/2) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,750 WARN L233 ceAbstractionStarter]: 1 thread instances were not sufficient, I will increase this number and restart the analysis [2023-11-17 22:44:45,751 INFO L514 ceAbstractionStarter]: Constructing petrified ICFG for 2 thread instances. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,783 INFO L144 ThreadInstanceAdder]: Constructed 2 joinOtherThreadTransitions. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,799 INFO L100 denceProviderFactory]: Independence Relation #1: [IndependenceType=SEMANTIC, AbstractionType=VARIABLES_GLOBAL, UseConditional=true, UseSemiCommutativity=true, Solver=Z3, SolverTimeout=1000ms] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,799 INFO L173 SolverBuilder]: Constructing external solver with command: z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,799 INFO L189 MonitoredProcess]: No working directory specified, using /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,803 INFO L229 MonitoredProcess]: Starting monitored process 4 with /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 (exit command is (exit), workingDir is null) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,804 INFO L327 MonitoredProcess]: [MP /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 (4)] Waiting until timeout for monitored process [2023-11-17 22:44:45,807 INFO L159 artialOrderCegarLoop]: Running PartialOrderCegarLoop with 1 independence relations. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,807 INFO L356 AbstractCegarLoop]: ======== Iteration 0 == of CEGAR loop == salethreadThread1of2ForFork0 ======== [2023-11-17 22:44:45,808 INFO L357 AbstractCegarLoop]: Settings: SEPARATE_VIOLATION_CHECK=true, mInterprocedural=true, mMaxIterations=1000000, mWatchIteration=1000000, mArtifact=RCFG, mInterpolation=FPandBP, mInterpolantAutomaton=STRAIGHT_LINE, mDumpAutomata=false, mAutomataFormat=ATS_NUMERATE, mDumpPath=., mDeterminiation=PREDICATE_ABSTRACTION, mMinimize=MINIMIZE_SEVPA, mHoare=true, mAutomataTypeConcurrency=PARTIAL_ORDER_FA, mHoareTripleChecks=INCREMENTAL, mHoareAnnotationPositions=LoopHeads, mDumpOnlyReuseAutomata=false, mLimitTraceHistogram=0, mErrorLocTimeLimit=0, mLimitPathProgramCount=0, mCollectInterpolantStatistics=true, mHeuristicEmptinessCheck=false, mHeuristicEmptinessCheckAStarHeuristic=ZERO, mHeuristicEmptinessCheckAStarHeuristicRandomSeed=1337, mHeuristicEmptinessCheckSmtFeatureScoringMethod=DAGSIZE, mSMTFeatureExtraction=false, mSMTFeatureExtractionDumpPath=., mOverrideInterpolantAutomaton=false, mMcrInterpolantMethod=WP, mPorIndependenceSettings=[Lde.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.lib.tracecheckerutils.partialorder.independence.IndependenceSettings;@637b9ebc, mLbeIndependenceSettings=[IndependenceType=SEMANTIC, AbstractionType=NONE, UseConditional=false, UseSemiCommutativity=true, Solver=Z3, SolverTimeout=1000ms] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,808 INFO L358 AbstractCegarLoop]: Starting to check reachability of 4 error locations. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,903 INFO L420 AbstractCegarLoop]: === Iteration 1 === Targeting salethreadErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE === [salethreadErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (and 1 more)] === [2023-11-17 22:44:45,903 INFO L160 PredicateUnifier]: Initialized classic predicate unifier [2023-11-17 22:44:45,903 INFO L85 PathProgramCache]: Analyzing trace with hash 938617705, now seen corresponding path program 1 times [2023-11-17 22:44:45,904 INFO L118 FreeRefinementEngine]: Executing refinement strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:45,904 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using trace check IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [2009738517] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,904 INFO L95 rtionOrderModulation]: Keeping assertion order NOT_INCREMENTALLY [2023-11-17 22:44:45,904 INFO L127 SolverBuilder]: Constructing new instance of SMTInterpol with explicit timeout -1 ms and remaining time -1 ms [2023-11-17 22:44:45,919 INFO L136 AnnotateAndAsserter]: Conjunction of SSA is unsat [2023-11-17 22:44:45,951 INFO L134 CoverageAnalysis]: Checked inductivity of 0 backedges. 0 proven. 0 refuted. 0 times theorem prover too weak. 0 trivial. 0 not checked. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,951 INFO L136 FreeRefinementEngine]: Strategy CAMEL found an infeasible trace [2023-11-17 22:44:45,951 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant generator IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [2009738517] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,952 INFO L158 FreeRefinementEngine]: IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [2009738517] provided 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences [2023-11-17 22:44:45,952 INFO L185 FreeRefinementEngine]: Found 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,952 INFO L198 FreeRefinementEngine]: Number of different interpolants: perfect sequences [2] imperfect sequences [] total 2 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,952 INFO L121 tionRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant automaton builder IpAbStrategyModuleStraightlineAll [2050515373] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,952 INFO L85 oduleStraightlineAll]: Using 1 perfect interpolants to construct interpolant automaton [2023-11-17 22:44:45,953 INFO L571 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has 3 states [2023-11-17 22:44:45,953 INFO L100 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using predicate unifier PredicateUnifier provided by strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:45,953 INFO L143 InterpolantAutomaton]: Constructing interpolant automaton starting with 3 interpolants. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,954 INFO L145 InterpolantAutomaton]: CoverageRelationStatistics Valid=3, Invalid=3, Unknown=0, NotChecked=0, Total=6 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,954 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,955 INFO L495 AbstractCegarLoop]: Abstraction has currently 0 states, but on-demand construction may add more states [2023-11-17 22:44:45,955 INFO L496 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has has 3 states, 2 states have (on average 14.0) internal successors, (28), 3 states have internal predecessors, (28), 0 states have call successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have return successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have call successors, (0) [2023-11-17 22:44:45,955 INFO L154 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to On-DemandConstruction mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,992 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 3 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:45,992 WARN L477 AbstractCegarLoop]: Destroyed unattended storables created during the last iteration: SelfDestructingSolverStorable4 [2023-11-17 22:44:45,992 INFO L420 AbstractCegarLoop]: === Iteration 2 === Targeting salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE === [salethreadErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (and 1 more)] === [2023-11-17 22:44:45,993 INFO L160 PredicateUnifier]: Initialized classic predicate unifier [2023-11-17 22:44:45,993 INFO L85 PathProgramCache]: Analyzing trace with hash 2123515793, now seen corresponding path program 1 times [2023-11-17 22:44:45,993 INFO L118 FreeRefinementEngine]: Executing refinement strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:45,993 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using trace check IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [1164021967] [2023-11-17 22:44:45,993 INFO L95 rtionOrderModulation]: Keeping assertion order NOT_INCREMENTALLY [2023-11-17 22:44:45,993 INFO L127 SolverBuilder]: Constructing new instance of SMTInterpol with explicit timeout -1 ms and remaining time -1 ms [2023-11-17 22:44:46,007 INFO L136 AnnotateAndAsserter]: Conjunction of SSA is unsat [2023-11-17 22:44:46,037 INFO L134 CoverageAnalysis]: Checked inductivity of 0 backedges. 0 proven. 0 refuted. 0 times theorem prover too weak. 0 trivial. 0 not checked. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,038 INFO L136 FreeRefinementEngine]: Strategy CAMEL found an infeasible trace [2023-11-17 22:44:46,038 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant generator IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [1164021967] [2023-11-17 22:44:46,038 INFO L158 FreeRefinementEngine]: IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [1164021967] provided 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences [2023-11-17 22:44:46,038 INFO L185 FreeRefinementEngine]: Found 1 perfect and 0 imperfect interpolant sequences. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,038 INFO L198 FreeRefinementEngine]: Number of different interpolants: perfect sequences [2] imperfect sequences [] total 2 [2023-11-17 22:44:46,038 INFO L121 tionRefinementEngine]: Using interpolant automaton builder IpAbStrategyModuleStraightlineAll [464057538] [2023-11-17 22:44:46,039 INFO L85 oduleStraightlineAll]: Using 1 perfect interpolants to construct interpolant automaton [2023-11-17 22:44:46,039 INFO L571 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has 3 states [2023-11-17 22:44:46,039 INFO L100 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using predicate unifier PredicateUnifier provided by strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:46,040 INFO L143 InterpolantAutomaton]: Constructing interpolant automaton starting with 3 interpolants. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,040 INFO L145 InterpolantAutomaton]: CoverageRelationStatistics Valid=3, Invalid=3, Unknown=0, NotChecked=0, Total=6 [2023-11-17 22:44:46,040 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,041 INFO L495 AbstractCegarLoop]: Abstraction has currently 0 states, but on-demand construction may add more states [2023-11-17 22:44:46,041 INFO L496 AbstractCegarLoop]: INTERPOLANT automaton has has 3 states, 2 states have (on average 15.5) internal successors, (31), 3 states have internal predecessors, (31), 0 states have call successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have return successors, (0), 0 states have call predecessors, (0), 0 states have call successors, (0) [2023-11-17 22:44:46,042 INFO L154 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to On-DemandConstruction mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 3 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,042 INFO L154 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to On-DemandConstruction mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 2 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,676 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 3 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,676 INFO L141 InterpolantAutomaton]: Switched to read-only mode: deterministic interpolant automaton has 3 states. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,677 WARN L477 AbstractCegarLoop]: Destroyed unattended storables created during the last iteration: SelfDestructingSolverStorable5 [2023-11-17 22:44:46,677 INFO L420 AbstractCegarLoop]: === Iteration 3 === Targeting salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE === [salethreadErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE, salethreadErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (and 1 more)] === [2023-11-17 22:44:46,677 INFO L160 PredicateUnifier]: Initialized classic predicate unifier [2023-11-17 22:44:46,678 INFO L85 PathProgramCache]: Analyzing trace with hash 1657137187, now seen corresponding path program 1 times [2023-11-17 22:44:46,678 INFO L118 FreeRefinementEngine]: Executing refinement strategy CAMEL [2023-11-17 22:44:46,678 INFO L334 FreeRefinementEngine]: Using trace check IpTcStrategyModuleSmtInterpolCraig [514078315] [2023-11-17 22:44:46,679 INFO L95 rtionOrderModulation]: Keeping assertion order NOT_INCREMENTALLY [2023-11-17 22:44:46,679 INFO L127 SolverBuilder]: Constructing new instance of SMTInterpol with explicit timeout -1 ms and remaining time -1 ms [2023-11-17 22:44:46,725 INFO L136 AnnotateAndAsserter]: Conjunction of SSA is sat [2023-11-17 22:44:46,727 INFO L356 TraceCheck]: Trace is feasible, we will do another trace check, this time with branch encoders. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,750 INFO L136 AnnotateAndAsserter]: Conjunction of SSA is sat [2023-11-17 22:44:46,769 INFO L130 FreeRefinementEngine]: Strategy CAMEL found a feasible trace [2023-11-17 22:44:46,770 INFO L360 BasicCegarLoop]: Counterexample is feasible [2023-11-17 22:44:46,770 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNSAFE for location salethreadErr1ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (3 of 4 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:46,770 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNKNOWN for location salethreadErr0ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (2 of 4 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:46,770 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNKNOWN for location salethreadErr2ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (1 of 4 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:46,771 INFO L805 garLoopResultBuilder]: Registering result UNKNOWN for location salethreadErr3ASSERT_VIOLATIONDATA_RACE (0 of 4 remaining) [2023-11-17 22:44:46,771 WARN L477 AbstractCegarLoop]: Destroyed unattended storables created during the last iteration: SelfDestructingSolverStorable6 [2023-11-17 22:44:46,780 INFO L445 BasicCegarLoop]: Path program histogram: [1, 1, 1] [2023-11-17 22:44:46,780 INFO L307 ceAbstractionStarter]: Result for error location salethreadThread1of2ForFork0 was UNSAFE,UNKNOWN,UNKNOWN,UNKNOWN (1/3) [2023-11-17 22:44:46,783 INFO L228 ceAbstractionStarter]: Analysis of concurrent program completed with 2 thread instances [2023-11-17 22:44:46,784 INFO L178 ceAbstractionStarter]: Computing trace abstraction results [2023-11-17 22:44:46,858 WARN L1572 BoogieBacktranslator]: Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated [2023-11-17 22:44:46,871 WARN L1572 BoogieBacktranslator]: Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated [2023-11-17 22:44:46,873 WARN L1572 BoogieBacktranslator]: Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated [2023-11-17 22:44:46,887 INFO L201 PluginConnector]: Adding new model de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.traceabstraction CFG 17.11 10:44:46 BasicIcfg [2023-11-17 22:44:46,887 INFO L131 PluginConnector]: ------------------------ END TraceAbstraction---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:46,888 INFO L112 PluginConnector]: ------------------------Witness Printer---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:46,888 INFO L270 PluginConnector]: Initializing Witness Printer... [2023-11-17 22:44:46,888 INFO L274 PluginConnector]: Witness Printer initialized [2023-11-17 22:44:46,889 INFO L184 PluginConnector]: Executing the observer RCFGCatcher from plugin Witness Printer for "de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.rcfgbuilder CFG 17.11 10:44:44" (3/4) ... [2023-11-17 22:44:46,891 INFO L140 WitnessPrinter]: No result that supports witness generation found [2023-11-17 22:44:46,892 INFO L131 PluginConnector]: ------------------------ END Witness Printer---------------------------- [2023-11-17 22:44:46,893 INFO L158 Benchmark]: Toolchain (without parser) took 4152.43ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 136.1MB in the beginning and 69.5MB in the end (delta: 66.7MB). Peak memory consumption was 68.3MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,893 INFO L158 Benchmark]: CDTParser took 0.25ms. Allocated memory is still 119.5MB. Free memory was 94.9MB in the beginning and 94.7MB in the end (delta: 169.8kB). There was no memory consumed. Max. memory is 16.1GB. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,894 INFO L158 Benchmark]: CACSL2BoogieTranslator took 683.50ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 135.6MB in the beginning and 116.2MB in the end (delta: 19.4MB). Peak memory consumption was 18.9MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,894 INFO L158 Benchmark]: Boogie Procedure Inliner took 54.78ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 116.2MB in the beginning and 114.1MB in the end (delta: 2.1MB). Peak memory consumption was 2.1MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,894 INFO L158 Benchmark]: Boogie Preprocessor took 39.08ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 114.1MB in the beginning and 112.0MB in the end (delta: 2.1MB). Peak memory consumption was 2.1MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,895 INFO L158 Benchmark]: RCFGBuilder took 664.40ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 112.0MB in the beginning and 94.8MB in the end (delta: 17.2MB). Peak memory consumption was 16.8MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,895 INFO L158 Benchmark]: TraceAbstraction took 2698.49ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 94.2MB in the beginning and 69.5MB in the end (delta: 24.8MB). Peak memory consumption was 26.4MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,896 INFO L158 Benchmark]: Witness Printer took 4.72ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory is still 69.5MB. There was no memory consumed. Max. memory is 16.1GB. [2023-11-17 22:44:46,899 INFO L338 ainManager$Toolchain]: ####################### End [Toolchain 1] ####################### --- Results --- * Results from de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.core: - StatisticsResult: Toolchain Benchmarks Benchmark results are: * CDTParser took 0.25ms. Allocated memory is still 119.5MB. Free memory was 94.9MB in the beginning and 94.7MB in the end (delta: 169.8kB). There was no memory consumed. Max. memory is 16.1GB. * CACSL2BoogieTranslator took 683.50ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 135.6MB in the beginning and 116.2MB in the end (delta: 19.4MB). Peak memory consumption was 18.9MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. * Boogie Procedure Inliner took 54.78ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 116.2MB in the beginning and 114.1MB in the end (delta: 2.1MB). Peak memory consumption was 2.1MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. * Boogie Preprocessor took 39.08ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 114.1MB in the beginning and 112.0MB in the end (delta: 2.1MB). Peak memory consumption was 2.1MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. * RCFGBuilder took 664.40ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 112.0MB in the beginning and 94.8MB in the end (delta: 17.2MB). Peak memory consumption was 16.8MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. * TraceAbstraction took 2698.49ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory was 94.2MB in the beginning and 69.5MB in the end (delta: 24.8MB). Peak memory consumption was 26.4MB. Max. memory is 16.1GB. * Witness Printer took 4.72ms. Allocated memory is still 176.2MB. Free memory is still 69.5MB. There was no memory consumed. Max. memory is 16.1GB. * Results from de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.cacsl2boogietranslator: - GenericResult: Unfinished Backtranslation Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated - GenericResult: Unfinished Backtranslation Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated - GenericResult: Unfinished Backtranslation Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated - GenericResult: Unfinished Backtranslation The program execution was not completely translated back. * Results from de.uni_freiburg.informatik.ultimate.plugins.generator.traceabstraction: - StatisticsResult: Independence relation #1 benchmarks IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 217, independent: 216, independent conditional: 4, independent unconditional: 212, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 1, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2031, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 60, dependent conditional: 47, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 14, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1450, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1450, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1438, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1438, dependent: 26, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 26, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 50, independent: 11, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 11, dependent: 39, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 39, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 521, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 521, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 1464, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 1464] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 212, Positive cache size: 212, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 212, Negative cache size: 0, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 0, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 1, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Independence relation #2 benchmarks IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 365, independent: 360, independent conditional: 9, independent unconditional: 351, dependent: 5, dependent conditional: 3, dependent unconditional: 2, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2031, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 60, dependent conditional: 47, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 14, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1450, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1450, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1438, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1438, dependent: 26, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 26, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 50, independent: 11, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 11, dependent: 39, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 39, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 521, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 521, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 1464, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 1464] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 501, Positive cache size: 499, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 499, Negative cache size: 2, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 2, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 4, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Independence relation #3 benchmarks IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 1449, independent: 1395, independent conditional: 160, independent unconditional: 1235, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 43, dependent unconditional: 11, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2031, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 60, dependent conditional: 47, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 14, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1450, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1450, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1438, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1438, dependent: 26, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 26, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 50, independent: 11, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 11, dependent: 39, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 39, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 521, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 521, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 1464, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 1464] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 1464, Positive cache size: 1450, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 1450, Negative cache size: 14, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 14, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 14, Maximal queried relation: 2, Independence queries for same thread: 40, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Persistent set benchmarks Persistent set computation time: 0.2s, Number of persistent set computation: 28, Number of trivial persistent sets: 25, Underlying independence relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 212, independent: 212, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 212, dependent: 0, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 217, independent: 216, independent conditional: 4, independent unconditional: 212, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 1, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2031, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 60, dependent conditional: 47, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 14, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1450, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1450, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1438, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1438, dependent: 26, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 26, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 50, independent: 11, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 11, dependent: 39, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 39, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 521, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 521, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 1464, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 1464] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 212, Positive cache size: 212, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 212, Negative cache size: 0, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 0, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 1, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Persistent set benchmarks Persistent set computation time: 0.0s, Number of persistent set computation: 31, Number of trivial persistent sets: 27, Underlying independence relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 353, independent: 351, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 351, dependent: 2, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 2, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 365, independent: 360, independent conditional: 9, independent unconditional: 351, dependent: 5, dependent conditional: 3, dependent unconditional: 2, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2031, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 60, dependent conditional: 47, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 14, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1450, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1450, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1438, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1438, dependent: 26, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 26, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 50, independent: 11, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 11, dependent: 39, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 39, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 521, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 521, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 1464, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 1464] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 501, Positive cache size: 499, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 499, Negative cache size: 2, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 2, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 4, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Persistent set benchmarks Persistent set computation time: 0.1s, Number of persistent set computation: 115, Number of trivial persistent sets: 96, Underlying independence relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1246, independent: 1235, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1235, dependent: 11, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 11, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 1449, independent: 1395, independent conditional: 160, independent unconditional: 1235, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 43, dependent unconditional: 11, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2031, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 60, dependent conditional: 47, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1991, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 173, independent unconditional: 1798, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 7, dependent unconditional: 13, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 14, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 1971, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1971, dependent: 34, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 34, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1450, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1450, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1464, independent: 1438, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 1438, dependent: 26, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 26, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 26, independent: 12, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 12, dependent: 14, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 14, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 50, independent: 11, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 11, dependent: 39, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 39, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 2005, independent: 521, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 521, dependent: 20, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 20, unknown: 1464, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 1464] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 1464, Positive cache size: 1450, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 1450, Negative cache size: 14, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 14, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 14, Maximal queried relation: 2, Independence queries for same thread: 40, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Independence relation #1 benchmarks IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 1, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 330, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 11, dependent conditional: 10, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 295, independent: 294, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 294, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 295, independent: 294, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 294, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 21, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 21, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 21, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 25, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 25, dependent: 0, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 295, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 295] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 0, Positive cache size: 0, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 0, Negative cache size: 0, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 0, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: -1, Independence queries for same thread: 1, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Independence relation #2 benchmarks IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 329, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 10, dependent conditional: 9, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 330, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 11, dependent conditional: 10, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 295, independent: 294, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 294, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 295, independent: 294, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 294, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 21, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 21, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 21, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 25, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 25, dependent: 0, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 295, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 295] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 295, Positive cache size: 294, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 294, Negative cache size: 1, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 1, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 10, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Persistent set benchmarks Persistent set computation time: 0.0s, Number of persistent set computation: 17, Number of trivial persistent sets: 17, Underlying independence relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 0, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 0, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 1, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 330, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 11, dependent conditional: 10, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 295, independent: 294, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 294, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 295, independent: 294, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 294, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 21, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 21, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 21, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 25, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 25, dependent: 0, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 295, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 295] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 0, Positive cache size: 0, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 0, Negative cache size: 0, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 0, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: -1, Independence queries for same thread: 1, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Persistent set benchmarks Persistent set computation time: 0.1s, Number of persistent set computation: 35, Number of trivial persistent sets: 35, Underlying independence relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 308, independent: 307, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 329, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 10, dependent conditional: 9, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 330, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 11, dependent conditional: 10, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 12, independent unconditional: 307, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 319, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 319, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 295, independent: 294, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 294, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 295, independent: 294, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 294, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 1, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 1, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 21, independent: 0, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 0, dependent: 21, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 21, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 320, independent: 25, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 25, dependent: 0, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 0, unknown: 295, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 295] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 295, Positive cache size: 294, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 294, Negative cache size: 1, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 1, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 10, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Independence relation #1 benchmarks IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 356, independent: 353, independent conditional: 4, independent unconditional: 349, dependent: 3, dependent conditional: 1, dependent unconditional: 2, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9643, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 883, dependent conditional: 832, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 75, independent unconditional: 8685, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 709, dependent unconditional: 387, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4080, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4080, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4033, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4033, dependent: 101, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 101, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 144, independent: 44, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 44, dependent: 100, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 100, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 4680, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4680, dependent: 1042, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1042, unknown: 4134, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 4134] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 351, Positive cache size: 349, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 349, Negative cache size: 2, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 2, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 1, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Independence relation #2 benchmarks IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 584, independent: 574, independent conditional: 9, independent unconditional: 565, dependent: 10, dependent conditional: 3, dependent unconditional: 7, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9643, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 883, dependent conditional: 832, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 75, independent unconditional: 8685, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 709, dependent unconditional: 387, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4080, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4080, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4033, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4033, dependent: 101, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 101, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 144, independent: 44, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 44, dependent: 100, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 100, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 4680, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4680, dependent: 1042, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1042, unknown: 4134, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 4134] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 753, Positive cache size: 744, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 744, Negative cache size: 9, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 9, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 4, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Independence relation #3 benchmarks IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 8703, independent: 7833, independent conditional: 3727, independent unconditional: 4106, dependent: 870, dependent conditional: 828, dependent unconditional: 42, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9643, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 883, dependent conditional: 832, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 75, independent unconditional: 8685, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 709, dependent unconditional: 387, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4080, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4080, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4033, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4033, dependent: 101, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 101, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 144, independent: 44, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 44, dependent: 100, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 100, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 4680, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4680, dependent: 1042, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1042, unknown: 4134, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 4134] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 4134, Positive cache size: 4080, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 4080, Negative cache size: 54, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 54, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 784, Maximal queried relation: 2, Independence queries for same thread: 483, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Persistent set benchmarks Persistent set computation time: 0.1s, Number of persistent set computation: 28, Number of trivial persistent sets: 27, Underlying independence relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 351, independent: 349, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 349, dependent: 2, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 2, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 356, independent: 353, independent conditional: 4, independent unconditional: 349, dependent: 3, dependent conditional: 1, dependent unconditional: 2, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9643, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 883, dependent conditional: 832, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 75, independent unconditional: 8685, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 709, dependent unconditional: 387, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4080, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4080, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4033, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4033, dependent: 101, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 101, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 144, independent: 44, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 44, dependent: 100, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 100, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 4680, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4680, dependent: 1042, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1042, unknown: 4134, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 4134] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 351, Positive cache size: 349, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 349, Negative cache size: 2, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 2, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 1, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Persistent set benchmarks Persistent set computation time: 0.0s, Number of persistent set computation: 31, Number of trivial persistent sets: 30, Underlying independence relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 572, independent: 565, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 565, dependent: 7, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 7, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 584, independent: 574, independent conditional: 9, independent unconditional: 565, dependent: 10, dependent conditional: 3, dependent unconditional: 7, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9643, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 883, dependent conditional: 832, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 75, independent unconditional: 8685, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 709, dependent unconditional: 387, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4080, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4080, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4033, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4033, dependent: 101, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 101, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 144, independent: 44, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 44, dependent: 100, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 100, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 4680, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4680, dependent: 1042, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1042, unknown: 4134, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 4134] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 753, Positive cache size: 744, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 744, Negative cache size: 9, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 9, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 0, Maximal queried relation: 0, Independence queries for same thread: 4, Statistics for Abstraction: - StatisticsResult: Persistent set benchmarks Persistent set computation time: 0.3s, Number of persistent set computation: 959, Number of trivial persistent sets: 541, Underlying independence relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4148, independent: 4106, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4106, dependent: 42, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 42, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Independence Queries: [ total: 8703, independent: 7833, independent conditional: 3727, independent unconditional: 4106, dependent: 870, dependent conditional: 828, dependent unconditional: 42, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , IndependenceRelationWithAbstraction.Statistics on underlying relation: ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9643, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 883, dependent conditional: 832, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ThreadSeparatingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9160, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 3740, independent unconditional: 5020, dependent: 400, dependent conditional: 349, dependent unconditional: 51, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , DisjunctiveConditionalIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 75, independent unconditional: 8685, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 709, dependent unconditional: 387, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticConditionEliminator.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticConditionEliminator.Statistics on underlying relation: CachedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 8760, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 8760, dependent: 1096, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1096, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , CachedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: UnionIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4080, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4080, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , UnionIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relations: [ SyntacticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 4134, independent: 4033, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4033, dependent: 101, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 101, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ProtectedIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , ConditionTransformingIndependenceRelation.Statistics on underlying relation: SemanticIndependenceRelation.Independence Queries: [ total: 101, independent: 47, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 47, dependent: 54, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 54, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , SemanticIndependenceRelation.Query Time [ms]: [ total: 144, independent: 44, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 44, dependent: 100, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 100, unknown: 0, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 0] , Protected Queries: 0 ], Cache Queries: [ total: 9856, independent: 4680, independent conditional: 0, independent unconditional: 4680, dependent: 1042, dependent conditional: 0, dependent unconditional: 1042, unknown: 4134, unknown conditional: 0, unknown unconditional: 4134] , Statistics on independence cache: Total cache size (in pairs): 4134, Positive cache size: 4080, Positive conditional cache size: 0, Positive unconditional cache size: 4080, Negative cache size: 54, Negative conditional cache size: 0, Negative unconditional cache size: 54, Unknown cache size: 0, Unknown conditional cache size: 0, Unknown unconditional cache size: 0, Eliminated conditions: 784, Maximal queried relation: 2, Independence queries for same thread: 483, Statistics for Abstraction: - DataRaceFoundResult [Line: 722]: Data race detected [2023-11-17 22:44:46,991 WARN L1572 BoogieBacktranslator]: Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated [2023-11-17 22:44:46,994 WARN L1572 BoogieBacktranslator]: Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated [2023-11-17 22:44:46,997 WARN L1572 BoogieBacktranslator]: Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated [2023-11-17 22:44:47,033 WARN L1572 BoogieBacktranslator]: Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated [2023-11-17 22:44:47,034 WARN L1572 BoogieBacktranslator]: Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated [2023-11-17 22:44:47,035 WARN L1572 BoogieBacktranslator]: Unfinished Backtranslation: IdentifierExpression #t~pre7 could not be translated Data race detected The following path leads to a data race: [L717] 0 int numberOfSeatsSold; VAL [numberOfSeatsSold=0] [L718] 0 int stopSales; VAL [numberOfSeatsSold=0, stopSales=0] [L719] 0 int numOfTickets; VAL [numOfTickets=0, numberOfSeatsSold=0, stopSales=0] [L736] 0 pthread_t salethreads[25]; VAL [\old(argc)=102, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, numOfTickets=0, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L738] 0 numOfTickets = 25 VAL [\old(argc)=102, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L741] 0 numberOfSeatsSold = 0 VAL [\old(argc)=102, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L744] 0 stopSales = 0 VAL [\old(argc)=102, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L746] 0 int i = 0; VAL [\old(argc)=102, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, i=0, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L746] COND TRUE 0 i < 25 VAL [\old(argc)=102, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, i=0, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L747] FCALL, FORK 0 pthread_create(&salethreads[i], 0, salethread, ((void *)0)) VAL [\old(argc)=102, arg={0:0}, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, i=0, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L721] 1 !stopSales VAL [arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, stopSales=0] [L721] COND TRUE 1 !stopSales VAL [arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, stopSales=0] [L722] 1 int _numberOfSeatsSold = numberOfSeatsSold; VAL [arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, stopSales=0] [L746] 0 i++ VAL [\old(argc)=102, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, i=1, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L746] COND TRUE 0 i < 25 VAL [\old(argc)=102, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, i=1, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L747] FCALL, FORK 0 pthread_create(&salethreads[i], 0, salethread, ((void *)0)) VAL [\old(argc)=102, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, i=1, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L746] 0 i++ VAL [\old(argc)=102, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, i=2, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L746] COND TRUE 0 i < 25 VAL [\old(argc)=102, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, i=2, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L747] FCALL, FORK 0 pthread_create(&salethreads[i], 0, salethread, ((void *)0)) VAL [\old(argc)=102, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, argc=102, argv={104:103}, argv={104:103}, i=2, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, salethreads={3:0}, stopSales=0] [L721] 2 !stopSales VAL [arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, stopSales=0] [L721] COND TRUE 2 !stopSales VAL [arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, stopSales=0] [L722] 2 int _numberOfSeatsSold = numberOfSeatsSold; VAL [_numberOfSeatsSold=0, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, stopSales=0] [L723] COND FALSE 2 !(_numberOfSeatsSold >= (25 - (((25 / 10) == 0) ? 1 : (25 / 10)))) VAL [_numberOfSeatsSold=0, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=0, stopSales=0] [L729] 2 numberOfSeatsSold = _numberOfSeatsSold + 1 VAL [_numberOfSeatsSold=0, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=1, stopSales=0] [L722] 1 int _numberOfSeatsSold = numberOfSeatsSold; VAL [_numberOfSeatsSold=0, arg={0:0}, arg={0:0}, numOfTickets=25, numberOfSeatsSold=1, stopSales=0] Now there is a data race on ~numberOfSeatsSold~0 between C: numberOfSeatsSold = _numberOfSeatsSold + 1 [729] and C: int _numberOfSeatsSold = numberOfSeatsSold; [722] - UnprovableResult [Line: 721]: Unable to prove that there are no data races Unable to prove that there are no data races Reason: Not analyzed. - UnprovableResult [Line: 725]: Unable to prove that there are no data races Unable to prove that there are no data races Reason: Not analyzed. - UnprovableResult [Line: 729]: Unable to prove that there are no data races Unable to prove that there are no data races Reason: Not analyzed. - StatisticsResult: Ultimate Automizer benchmark data for errors in thread instance: salethreadThread1of1ForFork0 with 1 thread instances CFG has 3 procedures, 105 locations, 14 error locations. Started 1 CEGAR loops. OverallTime: 1.0s, OverallIterations: 2, TraceHistogramMax: 0, PathProgramHistogramMax: 1, EmptinessCheckTime: 0.5s, AutomataDifference: 0.0s, DeadEndRemovalTime: 0.0s, HoareAnnotationTime: 0.0s, InitialAbstractionConstructionTime: 0.0s, HoareTripleCheckerStatistics: , PredicateUnifierStatistics: No data available, 0.0s BasicInterpolantAutomatonTime, BiggestAbstraction: size=0occurred in iteration=0, InterpolantAutomatonStates: 6, traceCheckStatistics: No data available, InterpolantConsolidationStatistics: No data available, PathInvariantsStatistics: No data available, 0/0 InterpolantCoveringCapability, TotalInterpolationStatistics: No data available, 0.0s DumpTime, AutomataMinimizationStatistics: No data available, HoareAnnotationStatistics: No data available, RefinementEngineStatistics: TRACE_CHECK: 0.0s SsaConstructionTime, 0.0s SatisfiabilityAnalysisTime, 0.2s InterpolantComputationTime, 59 NumberOfCodeBlocks, 59 NumberOfCodeBlocksAsserted, 2 NumberOfCheckSat, 57 ConstructedInterpolants, 0 QuantifiedInterpolants, 61 SizeOfPredicates, 0 NumberOfNonLiveVariables, 0 ConjunctsInSsa, 0 ConjunctsInUnsatCore, 2 InterpolantComputations, 2 PerfectInterpolantSequences, 0/0 InterpolantCoveringCapability, INVARIANT_SYNTHESIS: No data available, INTERPOLANT_CONSOLIDATION: No data available, ABSTRACT_INTERPRETATION: No data available, PDR: No data available, ACCELERATED_INTERPOLATION: No data available, SIFA: No data available, ReuseStatistics: No data available - StatisticsResult: Ultimate Automizer benchmark data for errors in thread instance: ULTIMATE.start with 1 thread instances CFG has 3 procedures, 105 locations, 14 error locations. Started 1 CEGAR loops. OverallTime: 0.4s, OverallIterations: 2, TraceHistogramMax: 0, PathProgramHistogramMax: 1, EmptinessCheckTime: 0.1s, AutomataDifference: 0.0s, DeadEndRemovalTime: 0.0s, HoareAnnotationTime: 0.0s, InitialAbstractionConstructionTime: 0.0s, HoareTripleCheckerStatistics: , PredicateUnifierStatistics: No data available, 0.0s BasicInterpolantAutomatonTime, BiggestAbstraction: size=0occurred in iteration=0, InterpolantAutomatonStates: 2, traceCheckStatistics: No data available, InterpolantConsolidationStatistics: No data available, PathInvariantsStatistics: No data available, 0/0 InterpolantCoveringCapability, TotalInterpolationStatistics: No data available, 0.0s DumpTime, AutomataMinimizationStatistics: No data available, HoareAnnotationStatistics: No data available, RefinementEngineStatistics: TRACE_CHECK: 0.0s SsaConstructionTime, 0.0s SatisfiabilityAnalysisTime, 0.0s InterpolantComputationTime, 52 NumberOfCodeBlocks, 52 NumberOfCodeBlocksAsserted, 2 NumberOfCheckSat, 16 ConstructedInterpolants, 0 QuantifiedInterpolants, 16 SizeOfPredicates, 0 NumberOfNonLiveVariables, 0 ConjunctsInSsa, 0 ConjunctsInUnsatCore, 1 InterpolantComputations, 1 PerfectInterpolantSequences, 0/0 InterpolantCoveringCapability, INVARIANT_SYNTHESIS: No data available, INTERPOLANT_CONSOLIDATION: No data available, ABSTRACT_INTERPRETATION: No data available, PDR: No data available, ACCELERATED_INTERPOLATION: No data available, SIFA: No data available, ReuseStatistics: No data available - StatisticsResult: Ultimate Automizer benchmark data for errors in thread instance: salethreadThread1of2ForFork0 with 1 thread instances CFG has 4 procedures, 123 locations, 18 error locations. Started 1 CEGAR loops. OverallTime: 1.0s, OverallIterations: 3, TraceHistogramMax: 0, PathProgramHistogramMax: 1, EmptinessCheckTime: 0.8s, AutomataDifference: 0.0s, DeadEndRemovalTime: 0.0s, HoareAnnotationTime: 0.0s, InitialAbstractionConstructionTime: 0.0s, HoareTripleCheckerStatistics: , PredicateUnifierStatistics: No data available, 0.0s BasicInterpolantAutomatonTime, BiggestAbstraction: size=0occurred in iteration=0, InterpolantAutomatonStates: 6, traceCheckStatistics: No data available, InterpolantConsolidationStatistics: No data available, PathInvariantsStatistics: No data available, 0/0 InterpolantCoveringCapability, TotalInterpolationStatistics: No data available, 0.0s DumpTime, AutomataMinimizationStatistics: No data available, HoareAnnotationStatistics: No data available, RefinementEngineStatistics: TRACE_CHECK: 0.0s SsaConstructionTime, 0.0s SatisfiabilityAnalysisTime, 0.1s InterpolantComputationTime, 119 NumberOfCodeBlocks, 119 NumberOfCodeBlocksAsserted, 3 NumberOfCheckSat, 57 ConstructedInterpolants, 0 QuantifiedInterpolants, 61 SizeOfPredicates, 0 NumberOfNonLiveVariables, 0 ConjunctsInSsa, 0 ConjunctsInUnsatCore, 2 InterpolantComputations, 2 PerfectInterpolantSequences, 0/0 InterpolantCoveringCapability, INVARIANT_SYNTHESIS: No data available, INTERPOLANT_CONSOLIDATION: No data available, ABSTRACT_INTERPRETATION: No data available, PDR: No data available, ACCELERATED_INTERPOLATION: No data available, SIFA: No data available, ReuseStatistics: No data available RESULT: Ultimate proved your program to be incorrect! [2023-11-17 22:44:47,085 INFO L540 MonitoredProcess]: [MP /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 (4)] Forceful destruction successful, exit code 0 [2023-11-17 22:44:47,285 INFO L540 MonitoredProcess]: [MP /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 (3)] Forceful destruction successful, exit code 0 [2023-11-17 22:44:47,487 INFO L540 MonitoredProcess]: [MP /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 -smt2 -in SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -t:1000 (2)] Forceful destruction successful, exit code 0 [2023-11-17 22:44:47,685 INFO L552 MonitoredProcess]: [MP /tmp/vcloud_worker_vcloud-master_on_vcloud-master/run_dir_a7ba7d6f-ce80-41a3-b861-0e793209f4ec/bin/ugemcutter-verify-ztSkJzofpW/z3 SMTLIB2_COMPLIANT=true -memory:2024 -smt2 -in -t:2000 (1)] Ended with exit code 0 Received shutdown request... --- End real Ultimate output --- Execution finished normally Writing output log to file Ultimate.log Writing human readable error path to file UltimateCounterExample.errorpath Result: FALSE